Jane Gallagher Is the Main Character of The Catcher in the Rye (Even If I Can't Prove It)
I know I'm wrong. I know the scholars will cite narrative theory, the teachers will point to page count, the Holden fans will accuse me of missing the point. But after reading J.D. Salinger's novel, I can't shake this conviction: Jane Gallagher is the main character of The Catcher in the Rye , and Holden is just the heartbroken narrator trying to tell her story without ruining it. This isn't an argument I can win on traditional terms. Jane never appears. She speaks no dialogue. She makes no decisions we witness directly. By every structural definition of "protagonist," Holden owns this novel. But here's what I believe: the people who love this book love Holden—his voice, his pain, his performance of adolescent despair. I love Jane. And I think Salinger did too, because he protected her in a way he protected nothing else in the novel. He kept her off the page, out of Holden's reach, safe from our analysis. And in doing so, he made her the only charact...