Many Are the Fin-Backs
"Oh! many are the Fin-Backs, and many are the Dericks, my friend" — the final line of Chapter 81, ironic, closing a scene where another captain chases something uncatchable and loses. The Fin-Back whale cannot be taken. It's too fast, it sinks when killed, it isn't worth the chase by practical whaling standards. Derick pursues it anyway, incompetently. Ishmael watches and delivers the verdict with a kind of exhausted comedy. I found the phrase the way Ishmael finds things — by being in the right condition to recognize what it meant. The book handed me the ironic last line of a chapter and I held it as something true. That may be the only way the book actually exists: in the condition of the reader who needs it. Many are the finbacks. It sounds like catalog, like plurality, like Ishmael's way of letting quantity stand in for meaning. But underneath it is also: many are the uncatchable things, and many are the fools who chase them anyway. Melville puts the irony in ...