The Raft and the Rock
Democracy, Capital, Faith, and the Question of What Remains “A democracy is a raft which would never sink, but then your feet are always in the water.” — Fisher Ames, 1788 I. The Raft Fisher Ames, in 1788, gave American political thought one of its most durable images. A monarchy, he said, is a merchantman—well-built, efficient, impressive in the harbor. But it sometimes strikes a rock and goes to the bottom. A democracy is a raft, which will never sink, but your feet are always in the water. The image was later extended: the dictatorship is the proud ship that strikes something hidden beneath the surface and founders. The raft gets tossed around badly, feet permanently wet, passengers arguing about which direction to paddle. But it gets to shore. The raft works because it is made of the same material as the water. It has give. It loses pieces and gains pieces. It reconfigures around obstacles because it was never rigid to begin with. The people on it built it themselves from whatever ...